Renovate vs Dependabot
Renovate vs Dependabot compared for 2026: Renovate 44.252 as a cross-platform, highly configurable update bot (AGPL-3.0, self-hosted or Mend-hosted) vs Dependabot as GitHub's built-in version and security update service with dependabot.yml, a 3-day default cooldown and grouped security PRs. Includes a Renovate dry run we did, Mend cloud plan limits, Dependabot PR limits, ecosystem coverage, auto-merge, private registries, self-hosting and a clear pick per situation.
Quick Answer
Renovate and Dependabot both open pull requests that bump your dependencies, but they come from different places. Dependabot is built into GitHub: you check in a dependabot.yml, and GitHub runs version updates and security updates for 34 package-ecosystem values on its own Actions infrastructure, free on every plan. Renovate (Mend, AGPL-3.0, 44.252.0 on 18 November 2026) is a bot you install as the Mend-hosted app or run yourself, on GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, Azure DevOps, Gitea or Forgejo, with about 120 managers and a much larger configuration surface. The day-to-day difference is noise control. Renovate ships community presets that group monorepo packages, a Dependency Dashboard issue, per-package schedules and release-age gates; Dependabot opens one PR per dependency until you write groups, caps open version PRs at 5 by default and waits 3 days before proposing a new version. In our dry run, Renovate turned 6 npm dependencies into 12 updates on 8 branches and held a 1-day-old typescript-eslint release back under a 3-day age rule. Pick Dependabot for GitHub repos that want zero setup and security PRs tied to GitHub's alerts; pick Renovate when you are not only on GitHub, run many repos or monorepos, or need fine-grained grouping and scheduling.
Last updated November 18, 2026. Covers Renovate 44.252.0 (18 November 2026) with the current docs (bot comparison, platforms, managers, configuration options, minimum release age, Mend-hosted plans and app configuration) and dependabot-core v0.405.0 (16 November 2026) with GitHub's Dependabot docs (version updates, security updates, supported ecosystems, options reference, auto-triage rules, automation with Actions) and Advanced Security billing, all read on 18 November 2026, plus a Renovate dry run we did the same day.
| Feature | Renovate | Dependabot |
|---|---|---|
| Licence & Maintainer | AGPL-3.0; maintained by Mend, written in TypeScript | dependabot-core is MIT, maintained by GitHub, written in Ruby; the hosted service is part of GitHub |
| How It Runs | Mend-hosted app (Community, Community OSS, Enterprise) or self-hosted CLI, Docker image or GitHub Action | Runs inside GitHub on GitHub Actions infrastructure |
| Git Platforms | Azure DevOps, Bitbucket Cloud/Server, Forgejo, Gitea, GitHub, GitLab; experimental: CodeCommit, Gerrit, local, SCM-Manager | GitHub.com and GitHub Enterprise Server; dependabot-core can open PRs on GitLab, Bitbucket, Azure DevOps and CodeCommit if you host it |
| Ecosystem Coverage | About 120 managers, including package managers, Dockerfiles, Helm, Terraform, CI configs and version files | 34 package-ecosystem values (npm, pnpm and Yarn share npm; pip covers pipenv and poetry) |
| Configuration | renovate.json (or .json5, package.json key and other locations) extending presets such as config:recommended | .github/dependabot.yml with one entry per ecosystem and directory |
| Grouping Updates | Community presets plus groupName and packageRules for any grouping you like | groups by pattern, dependency type or update type; multi-ecosystem-groups; grouped security updates per ecosystem |
| Monorepo Package Groups | Yes, group:monorepos via config:recommended | Manual groups; group-by dependency-name across directories |
| Overview of Pending Updates | Yes, Dependency Dashboard issue (enabled by config:recommended) | No dedicated issue; status under Insights > Dependency graph > Dependabot |
| Scheduling | Any schedule per repo, package, manager or update type; Mend cloud runs jobs every 4 hours (hourly on Enterprise) | daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly, semiannually, yearly or cron, per ecosystem entry |
| Default PR Limits | prHourlyLimit 2, prConcurrentLimit 10; security PRs are created even when the limit is reached | 5 open version PRs (open-pull-requests-limit); fixed 10 for security PRs |
| Release-Age Gate | minimumReleaseAge, per package rule; honours pnpm and Yarn age settings | Default 3-day cooldown on version updates, configurable with cooldown; not applied to security updates |
| Security Updates | Reads GitHub vulnerability alerts (GitHub only) or experimental osv.dev alerts; [SECURITY] PRs bypass schedules and limits by default | Built in: alerts from GitHub's advisory database; security updates PR the minimum patched version |
| Transitive Dependency Fixes | Fixes via lock file updates (rangeStrategy update-lockfile for vulnerability PRs); lockFileMaintenance refreshes whole lock files | Depends on ecosystem: npm updates the parent, NuGet PackageReference can pin; others cannot if a parent bump is required |
| Auto-merge | Built in: automerge PRs or branches per rule, optionally using the platform's native auto-merge | Through your own GitHub Actions workflow, for example using dependabot/fetch-metadata |
| Custom File Formats | Yes, regex and JSONata custom managers | No |
| Post-upgrade Commands | postUpgradeTasks, blocked unless the admin allows commands via allowedCommands | No |
| Private Registries | hostRules with credentials; encrypted secrets or Mend portal credentials on the hosted app | registries block in dependabot.yml with secrets, for most ecosystems |
| Self-hosting | Officially supported on all listed platforms | Dependabot CLI and dependabot-core for standalone use; not officially supported outside GitHub |
| Update Confidence Signals | Merge Confidence badges: Age, Adoption, Passing, Confidence (workflows on OSS and Enterprise Mend plans) | One compatibility score badge based on CI results in other repositories |
| Price | Open source and free to self-host; Mend Community cloud free; Enterprise cloud price not published | Free on all plans; custom alert auto-triage rules need GitHub Code Security |
| Latest Release (Nov 2026) | 44.252.0 (18 November 2026) | dependabot-core v0.405.0 (16 November 2026) |
Renovate
Renovate is an open-source dependency update bot maintained by Mend. It scans a repository for package files with about 120 managers (npm, Docker, Terraform, Helm, Gradle, GitHub Actions, Bazel, asdf and many CI formats), looks up new versions from their datasources and opens branches and pull requests according to a JSON configuration that can extend shared presets. It runs as the Mend-hosted app or self-hosted from npm, Docker images or a GitHub Action.
Pros
- Works on GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket Cloud and Server, Azure DevOps, Gitea and Forgejo, with Gerrit, CodeCommit and SCM-Manager marked experimental
- config:recommended groups common monorepos (React, typescript-eslint and others) and separates minor from major updates out of the box
- Dependency Dashboard issue lists every pending, rate-limited and held update in one place
- Very fine control: schedules, minimumReleaseAge, automerge and grouping per package, manager or update type via packageRules
- Custom managers (regex or JSONata) update versions in any file format, and shared presets let one config govern hundreds of repos
- Free Mend-hosted Community plan covers unlimited public and private repositories
Cons
- Large configuration surface: hundreds of options, so debugging why an update did or did not appear takes log reading
- AGPL-3.0 licence, which some legal teams review before self-hosting a modified copy
- Free Mend cloud plan runs 1 concurrent job per org on a 4-hour schedule, so busy orgs see slower updates
- Security fixes from GitHub alerts need the Dependabot alerts permission on GitHub, and the OSV-based alerts are experimental and cover direct dependencies only
- Self-hosting the current CLI needs Node.js 24.11+ or 26.13+; it failed on Node 22 in our test
Best For
Teams on GitLab, Bitbucket, Azure DevOps or self-hosted Git, organisations managing many repositories or monorepos with shared presets, and anyone who wants grouping, schedules and release-age rules tuned per package.
Dependabot
Dependabot is GitHub's built-in dependency update service. Dependabot alerts flag vulnerable dependencies from GitHub's dependency graph, security updates open PRs to the minimum patched version, and version updates, configured in .github/dependabot.yml, keep dependencies current on a schedule. Jobs run on GitHub Actions infrastructure; the update logic is the open-source dependabot-core library.
Pros
- Nothing to install on GitHub: add dependabot.yml for version updates, flip a setting for security updates
- Security updates are wired to GitHub's advisory database and alerts, and merged fixes close the alert
- Free on every GitHub plan, including private repositories
- Sane defaults for noise: 3-day cooldown on version updates and at most 5 open version PRs per ecosystem entry
- Covers 34 package-ecosystem values, including uv, Bun, Deno, OpenTofu, Terraform, pre-commit, Rust toolchain, Bazel, Conda and dev containers
- Signs its commits and pauses itself when maintainers stop interacting with its PRs
Cons
- Officially a GitHub product; other platforms need the Dependabot CLI or community projects you operate yourself
- One PR per dependency until you write groups; no built-in monorepo presets
- No dashboard of pending updates comparable to Renovate's issue
- Auto-merge needs a separate GitHub Actions workflow; custom auto-triage rules for alerts require GitHub Code Security ($30 per active committer per month)
- Fewer knobs: no per-package schedules, no custom file formats, no post-upgrade commands
Best For
Repositories hosted on GitHub that want dependency and security updates with minimal setup, small teams, and organisations that already use GitHub Advanced Security for alert triage.
Where each one runs, and what that means for setup
Dependabot is part of GitHub. Security updates are a repository or organisation setting; version updates start when you commit .github/dependabot.yml with a package-ecosystem, directory and schedule per entry. GitHub runs the jobs on its Actions infrastructure, and the docs note that when Dependabot is enabled it always runs, bypassing Actions policy checks and Actions being disabled for the repository or organisation. There is no server to run and no token to manage. Renovate is a program you either install as the Mend-hosted app or run yourself. The hosted app has three plans: Community (free, unlimited public and private repositories, 1 concurrent job per org, jobs every 4 hours, 1 vCPU, 3 GB RAM, 30-minute timeout), Community OSS for OSI-licensed projects on request (2 concurrent jobs, 6 GB, 60 minutes, Merge Confidence workflows) and Enterprise (16 concurrent jobs, hourly scheduling, 2 vCPU, 8 GB, helpdesk support, price on request). Self-hosting means running the npm package, Docker image or GitHub Action on a schedule with a bot token. Mend notes the hosted app can lag the open-source release by hours to a week. Renovate's own comparison page also points out that it is the one of the two officially supported beyond GitHub.
Noise control: grouping, limits, schedules and release age
The most common complaint about update bots is PR spam, and the two tools default differently. Dependabot opens one pull request per outdated dependency and stops at 5 open version PRs per configured entry; security PRs have a separate fixed limit of 10. It also waits 3 days by default after a release before proposing a version update, configurable with cooldown, and you can group by name patterns, dependency type, semver level, across directories or across ecosystems. All of that is opt-in YAML you write yourself. Renovate's config:recommended preset groups known monorepos out of the box, separates major from minor updates, creates a Dependency Dashboard issue, and rate-limits to 2 new PRs per hour and 10 open, while still letting [SECURITY] PRs through. Schedules can apply to a single package, a manager or an update type, and minimumReleaseAge holds versions until they are old enough, which doubles as a defence against a freshly published malicious release. The trade-off is that Renovate's flexibility is also its learning curve: packageRules ordering and preset inheritance are where most surprises come from.
Security updates and vulnerable transitive dependencies
Dependabot's security side is the more integrated one. Dependabot alerts come from GitHub's advisory database matched against the dependency graph; when security updates are on, Dependabot tries to open a PR for every open alert with a patch, bumping to the minimum fixed version, and merging closes the alert. You can group security updates per ecosystem, and GitHub presets can auto-dismiss low-impact alerts in npm development dependencies; custom auto-triage rules are a GitHub Code Security feature. Transitive fixes depend on ecosystem: npm can update the parent, NuGet PackageReference can add a pinning reference, and other ecosystems cannot fix a transitive dependency if the parent must move. Renovate can consume the same GitHub alerts if the Dependabot alerts permission is granted, creating vulnerability PRs with rangeStrategy update-lockfile that skip schedules and limits by default. Off GitHub, its osvVulnerabilityAlerts option queries a locally downloaded OSV database, but it is flagged experimental and only covers direct dependencies for crate, go, hackage, hex, maven, npm, nuget, packagist, pypi and rubygems datasources. If vulnerability alerting is your main requirement and you are on GitHub, Dependabot alone is enough.
Ecosystems, custom files and running commands after an update
Coverage overlaps heavily for mainstream stacks. Dependabot's supported-ecosystems table lists 34 package-ecosystem values on 18 November 2026, including newer ones such as uv (v0.11), Bun 1.1.39+ text lockfiles, Deno 2, OpenTofu, Terraform up to 1.15.x, pre-commit hooks, Rust toolchain files, Bazel, Conda, Julia, Nix, vcpkg and dev container Features. Renovate's manager directory had 121 modules the same day, which adds many CI formats (CircleCI, Buildkite, Azure Pipelines, Bitbucket Pipelines), Argo CD, Ansible Galaxy, asdf and others. The bigger difference is extensibility. Renovate's customManagers extract versions from any file with a regex or a JSONata query, so a version pinned in a Makefile or a YAML values file can still be bumped; Dependabot has no equivalent. Renovate can also run postUpgradeTasks, such as code generation after a bump, but only commands the bot admin allows in allowedCommands, and on the Mend-hosted app this depends on plan. Dependabot keeps a smaller surface: its insecure-external-code-execution option only controls whether package manager code may run during updates for some ecosystems.
Worked example: one package.json through Renovate's dry run
On 18 November 2026 we ran Renovate 44.252.0 locally (platform local, dry-run lookup) on a throwaway repo whose package.json pinned express 4.18.2, react and react-dom 18.2.0, typescript 5.4.5 and @typescript-eslint/parser and eslint-plugin 7.8.0, with config:recommended plus minimumReleaseAge 3 days. It finished in about 9 seconds and planned 12 updates on 8 branches: renovate/react-monorepo (both React packages to 18.3.1) and renovate/major-react-monorepo (19.3.1), renovate/typescript-eslint-monorepo (7.18.0) and its major branch (8.72.2), plus separate minor and major branches for express (4.22.3, 5.3.0) and typescript (5.9.3, 7.0.2). typescript-eslint 8.73.0 was listed as pending because it was younger than 3 days. Our first attempt on Node 22.23 crashed with RegExp.escape is not a function; Renovate 44 declares Node 24.11+ or 26.13+. We did not run Dependabot, which needs GitHub or the Docker-based CLI. Per its docs, the same manifest without groups would get one PR per dependency, capped at 5 open, and the two React packages would only share a PR if you defined a group.
Verdict
Pick Dependabot when your code lives on GitHub and you want dependency hygiene with almost no setup: turn on alerts and security updates, add a short dependabot.yml with weekly version updates and a couple of groups, and let the default 3-day cooldown and the 5-PR cap keep the noise down. It is the right default for small teams and single repositories, and the security side is hard to beat because it is wired to GitHub's own alerts. Pick Renovate when any of these is true: you host on GitLab, Bitbucket, Azure DevOps, Gitea or Forgejo; you manage dozens or hundreds of repositories and want one shared preset to govern them; you have monorepos where React, Angular or typescript-eslint packages must move together; or you need versions bumped in files Dependabot does not understand. Expect to spend a day on configuration and to read logs now and then. Running both is common on GitHub: Dependabot alerts and security updates for vulnerabilities, Renovate for routine version updates, with Dependabot version updates switched off so the two do not fight over the same manifests.